What Can We Learn From Detroit?

Detroit Michigan occupied my thoughts today. First hand knowledge of Detroit’s blight is limited at best; I’ve seen photographs, know the city declared bankruptcy last year – a circumstance pitting “bond holders” against services, salaries and pensions. Hundreds of thousands have abandoned neighborhoods in search of jobs – Detroit has the highest unemployment and poverty rates in America. Schools, hospitals, factories, office buildings and civic structures languish in a surreal laboratory dedicated to structural decay. What little money there is goes to maintaining upper and middle class neighborhoods – poor, predominantly black residents left to wallow in an absurdly bleak parallel dimension.

http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2014/02/detroits-bankruptcy

Reasons for the decline of Detroit – highest property taxes in America, rampant government excess offering massive incentives and tax breaks to fund stadiums, casinos, office building with negligent return, bloated union controlled services, devastating factory and assembly plant closures, dissemination and displacement of black communities under the guise of “urban renewal” – translation; uproot and deposit in bleak government built highrise “projects” – I don’t really know, pick one or all of the above. One thing I do know –  the largest American city to declare bankruptcy places Detroit in the spotlight, don’t fool yourself into thinking it makes this an isolated or unique situation.

Detroit stands as a blazing example of misplaced priorities, shameful patronage, absurdly skewed expectations, racial inequality, misguided leadership, exclusion, favoritism, willful neglect and back room shenanigans.  Detroit should serve as a cautionary tale, an opportunity to reflect on the reality of America. In a perfect world people would stand up and take notice – Detroit isn’t an isolated situation.

Speaking from personal experience – a premature Interstate exit deposited us in East St. Louis. East St. Louis wasn’t on my radar, I had no way of preparing, let alone digesting the reality of racial and economic divide. Not threatening or scary – completely and utterly beaten into the ground. Late evening should have been dotted by street lights, closer inspection showed they weren’t simply burnt out –  smashed glass, torn out wires were just the beginning. Broken pavement, gaping pot holes,  block after dark block of forsaken businesses. A former hospital, 5 or 6 story brick construction likely circa 1960 – at first glance abandoned, then the realization people live behind broken windows. Candles illuminate makeshift window coverings, in the distance a small fire burns. Eerily silent, hopeless and by all appearances completely forsaken.

We could spend the next 100 years splitting hairs and pointing fingers, or use Detroit as an opportunity to smarten up. Look around – Detroit, St. Louis, Gary, Indiana – it doesn’t matter where you are, what counts is where we’re going.

stlouispatina.com

http://www.globalresearch.ca

weburbanist.com

 

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “What Can We Learn From Detroit?

  1. Thought provoking piece here Notes. Urban decay is prevalent throughout the U.S. Even in smaller communities there is flight to the suburbs, leaving core cities struggling to maintain their values and their worth.
    Would be interesting to compare U.S. cities to European cities. And see what, if any, culture differences there are.

    • I can only speak of my travel to London and Paris – by all accounts many of the same problems exist.in terms of low income,housing projects and cities exclusive to the very rich and extremely poor. What I didn’t see was the blatant disregard for basic infrastructure. The slums of Paris bear no resemblance to a third world country or war zone – two of the thoughts that crossed my mind in East St. Louis :).

    • Vancouver’s downtown east side is considered the poorest postal code in Canada.I could write pages explaining the problems and the causes – a short summary instead – addiction, mental illness, and concentration of SROs (single room occupancy) “hotels” – essentially run down rooms rented for the going government welfare housing allowance.

      That said – not in this neighborhood, or any neighborhood in any city in Canada will you find burnt out street lights, neglected roads, decaying buildings full of squatters or lack of police presence. I’m not saying it’s pretty – prostitution, high crime, open heroin and crack use, squalid buildings – but what it isn’t is utterly abandoned.or swept under the carpet.

      If I hadn’t seen East St. Louis with my own eyes I wouldn’t have believed it possible.America is in a heap of trouble – I wonder how far behind the rest of us are. Truly sobering.

      • There are so many pieces of where neglect takes place in the States…something is lost ~ apathy from politicians has trickled down to the streets…and apathy cannot be cured quickly. It is a bit frightening how easy it is to look away and pretend everything will be OK.
        Thanks again for this post.

  2. Pingback: Wordpress Blogs - Wordpress Blogs .NET

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s